[x-pubpol] Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales attacks government's 'snooper's charter'

[Joly MacFie]

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/sep/05/wikipedia-jimmy-wales-snoopers-charter


Jimmy Wales says his website would encrypt all connections with
Britain, and called the plans 'technologically incompetent'


Jimmy Wales, the Wikipedia founder, has sharply criticised the
government's so-called "snooper's charter", which will track the
internet, text and email use of all British citizens, as
"technologically incompetent".

Wales said that Wikipedia would move to encrypt all its connections
with Britain if UK internet companies, such as Vodafone and Virgin
Media, were mandated by the government to keep track of every single
page accessed by UK citizens.

The Wikipedia founder said he was confident there would be a general
move to encryption across the internet industry if British-based
communication service providers were required to collect and store
data for 12 months from overseas companies, such as Google and
Facebook, for possible access by the police and security services.

He said the British government would have to resort to the "black
arts" of hacking to break the encryption: "It is not the sort of thing
I would expect from a western democracy. It is the kind of thing I
would expect from the Iranians or the Chinese and it would be detected
immediately by the internet industry," Wales told MPs and peers.

His intervention came as leading UK internet companies, including
Vodafone and Virgin Media, also raised concerns that making them
responsible for retaining and storing sensitive data from overseas
third-party companies will damage their commercial relationships and
put them at a competitive disadvantage.

The internet industry, which is giving evidence to a parliamentary
special select committee on the draft communications data bill, said
that the legislation could create new opportunities for hackers and
"malicious agents" looking to get hold of sensitive private
information about individuals.

One leading internet industry organisation the London Internet
Exchange (Linx), told MPs that it had serious concerns the proposals
will create a "profiling engine", a filtering system that will produce
detailed profiles on all users of electronic communications systems,
that would enable sophisticated data mining.

In a written submission, Linx said it will be a challenge to safeguard
this profiling engine, and any breach would amount to "a significant
threat to national security".

"In our opinion this profiling engine amounts to an enormously
powerful tool for public authorities. Its mere existence significantly
implicates privacy rights, and its extensive use would represent a
dramatic shift in the balance between personal privacy and the
capabilities of the state to investigate and analyse the citizen," the
Linx submission said.

The £1.8bn scheme will require UK-based internet and phone providers
to retain and store for 12 months the "traffic data" – who sent what,
to whom, from where – but not the content of every British citizen's
internet, text and mobile phone use.

But the Home Office has admitted it cannot force foreign companies
such as Google and Facebook to store and hand over sensitive personal
data. Instead it is hoping to rely on voluntary agreements, but the
legislation includes powers to require British communication companies
to collect and store such third-party data that cross their networks.

Home Office security officials estimate that the rapidly evolving
nature of the internet means they can no longer keep track of up to
25% of communications data, despite it being used as vital evidence in
the vast majority of terrorist and serious crime cases. Internet and
phone companies currently only keep the data they collect for their
own business billing purposes.

The Internet Service Providers Association said the government
estimated that this "gap" could be reduced by 10% and questioned
whether this was sufficient to justify the proposals or represented
value for money.

-- 
---------------------------------------------------------------
Joly MacFie  218 565 9365 Skype:punkcast
WWWhatsup NYC - http://wwwhatsup.com
 http://pinstand.com - http://punkcast.com
 VP (Admin) - ISOC-NY - http://isoc-ny.org
--------------------------------------------------------------
-
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.isoc-ny.org/pipermail/x-pubpol-isoc-ny.org/attachments/20120905/4a093e0e/attachment-0001.htm>